CHRD
CONFIRMED ROADKILLExecutive Summary
4 LLMs analyzed CHRD. The stock trades at 2.5-3.7x EV/EBITDA with a 17% FCF yield. All models agree the balance sheet is safe (fortress-level). The Treadmill Test passes with 11-16% true net cannibalization. Fidelity's 11.2% stake provides institutional validation. Classification: CONFIRMED ROADKILL — the market appears to be pricing in fears that the fundamentals don't support.
vs. 6x peer avg
~$856M TTM
Fortress balance sheet
@ $90.04
Cross-LLM Analysis
| Model | Assessment | Key Thesis |
|---|---|---|
🟣Claude Opus4.5 | Roadkill Confirmed | "Cyclical Cannibal" — buybacks at distressed valuations |
🔵Gemini3 | Roadkill Confirmed | "4-Mile Revolution" — tech moat ignored |
🟢GPT-4o5.2 | More Research Needed | "Commodity bet" — cheap but no moat |
🟠Perplexity | More Research Needed | "Needs verification" — 10-K/10-Q gaps |
Treadmill Test
Shareholders gaining significant ground
Scenario Analysis
The Debate
Click to expand each model's analysis and see how they respond to each other.
CHRD trades at 3.2x EV/EBITDA — objectively cheap even for E&P. The market is treating this like a melting ice cube, but the math tells a different story.
The Cannibal Thesis: CHRD generated $856M in FCF last year and spent $590M on buybacks. That's an 11% true net cannibalization rate after accounting for SBC (which is negligible at 0.5% of market cap).
Balance sheet is a fortress — 0.36x Net Debt/EBITDA, 15x+ interest coverage. This company isn't going bankrupt.
Attractive FCF and valuation for a cyclical E&P, yet requires deeper primary-filing workand commodity/asset modeling before a high-conviction assessment.
I could not fully complete the Treadmill Test with available data. (Note: This is the correct response when data isn't verified.)
SEC EDGAR Filing Alert
FMR LLC (Fidelity) disclosed an 11.2% stake in CHRD
Filed October 7, 2025 • 6,352,348 shares • Schedule 13G/A (Passive)
This is "smart money" validation that wasn't caught in the original analysis.
Why it matters:
- 11% is a conviction position, not a passive index allocation
- 13G (not 13D) means passive — they're not activists
- Filing was near the stock's lows (~$85-90 range)
Interpretation: Major institutional investor sees value at current prices.
⚠️ Human Verification Status
- ✅ 13G/13D institutional filings (Fidelity 11.2% stake found)
- ✅ Drilling physics research (4-mile laterals validated)
- ☐ Form 4 insider transactions
- ☐ Glassdoor/LinkedIn employee sentiment