Archived research. Equity forecasting is part of the Runchey Research archive (methodology era 1) and is no longer actively updated. Everything remains published at its original URL. Browse the archive
Will Costco's trailing twelve-month gross margin fall below 12.5% by end of FY2026?
Current Prediction
Prediction History
Q2 FY2026 core-on-core gross margin +22bps broad-based widened the buffer; bear case probability reduced from 17% to 10%.
Why This Question Matters
Gross margin has been a positive indicator — expanding 59bps over 3 years from 12.26% to 12.85%. But the current 35bps buffer above the 12.5% escalation threshold is thin given Section 122 tariffs at 10-15%. The Moat Mapper uses gross margin as evidence of improving buying power (cost advantage moat), and compression below 12.5% would reverse the 3-year expansion trend and challenge the 'stable, leaning widening' moat trajectory assessment.
Prediction Distribution
Individual Predictions(5 runs)
Q2 results confirmed gross margin trajectory is positive, not pressured. Core-on-core +22bps in Q2 indicates buying power and category mix improvements offsetting tariff pressure. The 5bps benefit from a non-recurring legal settlement is small — the underlying trend is genuinely positive. With Section 122 likely to expire without replacement (separate market at ~57% expiry-without-replacement), the dominant external pressure on gross margin should ease, not intensify. Reducing from 0.17 prior batch to 0.10. Path to YES requires either a major tariff escalation or a competitive-pricing scenario neither of which is in the visible information set.
Going slightly below the cluster. The 35bps buffer is now effectively wider after Q2's +22bps core-on-core expansion. To compress below 12.5% would require ~50bps of erosion in remaining quarters of FY2026. That would require major tariff escalation OR competitive pricing war OR product mix shift toward lower-margin categories. None observed. Reducing to 0.08.
Aligning with opus run 1. Q2 gross margin trajectory was unambiguously positive. The buffer widened. Path to YES is narrow — major tariff shock or unexpected competitive pricing. Probability ~10%.
Slightly above the cluster on residual considerations: (1) LIFO charge reverted to a $12M cost in Q2 vs prior year credit — suggests cost inflation creeping back in nonfoods/general merchandise; (2) Costco has explicitly stated they 'did not pass the full cost' of tariffs onto members in some cases — implying willingness to absorb margin pressure; (3) the Q3 print falls in the Section 122-still-active window before expiry. These keep some residual probability of margin compression.
Q2 +22bps core-on-core. Buffer widened. Probability falls to ~10%.
Resolution Criteria
Resolves YES if Costco's trailing twelve-month gross margin (net sales minus merchandise costs, divided by net sales) falls below 12.50% as reported in the FY2026 10-K (expected September 2026 filing). Resolves NO if TTM gross margin remains at or above 12.50%.
Resolution Source
Costco 10-K FY2026 income statement — gross profit divided by net sales
Source Trigger
Gross margin compression below 12.5%
Full multi-lens equity analysis