Archived research. Equity forecasting is part of the Runchey Research archive (methodology era 1) and is no longer actively updated. Everything remains published at its original URL. Browse the archive

Back to Forecasting
MSActive

Will Morgan Stanley's named Section 16 officers conduct additional discretionary open-market sales exceeding $10M in aggregate during Q2 2026?

Resolves July 15, 2026(10d)
IG: 0.64

Current Prediction

62%
Likely Yes
Model Agreement88%
Predictions9 runs
Last UpdatedApril 13, 2026

Why This Question Matters

The January 2026 unanimous Section 16 officer selling cluster was the behavioral counter-signal to the 'higher plane' narrative. A repeat cluster in Q2 2026 post-Q1-earnings would strengthen the MIXED governance assessment toward MISALIGNED. Cessation would reduce concerns.

GOVERNANCE_ALIGNMENT

Prediction Distribution

0%25%50%75%100%
opus
sonnet
haiku
Range: 58%65%Aggregate: 62%
Individual Predictions(9 runs)
opusRun 1
65%

The January 2026 cluster was a clear pattern of coordinated post-earnings window discretionary selling. PSU vesting in Q2 creates fresh tranches to sell. The culture allows discretionary sales. Counter: governance optics after the Jan cluster will be scrutinized. The $10M threshold is modest given Jan was $25M+. Lean YES at 65%.

Established pattern from JanQ2 vesting creates tranches$10M modest vs Jan $25M
opusRun 2
60%

The pattern is established but stock has declined 13% from the January peak, reducing the attractiveness of another cluster at current prices. Executives may wait for stock to recover toward $180+ before selling again. However, Q2 window opens post-Q1 earnings and vesting cycles continue. Lean YES at 60%.

Stock down 13% reduces sell appealQ2 window opens post-earningsVesting cycles continue
opusRun 3
58%

The $10M threshold is absolute not incremental, so it requires meaningful aggregate selling in Q2. Given the Jan cluster at $25M, repeating it or hitting $10M specifically is plausible. The governance scrutiny factor pushes probability down somewhat. Net around 58%.

$10M absolute thresholdJan $25M precedentGovernance scrutiny counter
sonnetRun 1
62%

The Jan 2026 pattern strongly favors YES. Stock recovery toward $170-180 range would make Q2 window attractive. $10M is achievable if even 4-5 executives sell at typical discretionary sizes.

Jan pattern favors YES$10M achievable with 4-5 execsRange attractive for Q2 window
sonnetRun 2
65%

Strong precedent plus predictable vesting plus modest threshold. Lean YES at 65%. The governance optics concern is real but the pattern was already public for Q1 and did not stop the cluster.

Strong precedentPredictable vestingGovernance optics did not stop Jan
sonnetRun 3
60%

The Jan precedent is clear but Q2 may see adjustment toward 10b5-1 plans instead of discretionary. The resolution criteria exclude 10b5-1, which materially reduces the probability of hitting $10M in discretionary alone. Lean YES at 60% but with uncertainty about the 10b5-1 substitution.

10b5-1 substitution riskJan precedent clearResolution excludes 10b5-1
haikuRun 1
62%

Lean YES at 62%. Strong Jan precedent plus vesting cycles.

Strong precedentVesting cyclesLean YES
haikuRun 2
60%

Lean YES given precedent but the stock decline and governance scrutiny create modest headwinds. 60%.

Lean YESStock decline headwindGovernance scrutiny
haikuRun 3
65%

The pattern is too strong to discount. $10M is modest. Lean YES at 65%.

Pattern too strongModest threshold65%

Resolution Criteria

Resolves YES if Morgan Stanley named executive officers (NEOs in the most recent proxy) file Form 4 disclosures showing cumulative discretionary open-market sales (excluding tax withholding dispositions and 10b5-1 pre-planned sales) exceeding $10M in aggregate between April 14, 2026 and June 30, 2026. Resolves NO otherwise.

Resolution Source

SEC EDGAR Form 4 filings for Morgan Stanley insiders

Source Trigger

Executive Discretionary Selling — additional discretionary (non-10b5-1) selling in Q2 2026 post-Q1-earnings window

insider-investigatorGOVERNANCE_ALIGNMENTHIGH
View MS Analysis

Full multi-lens equity analysis