Back to Forecasting
MSActive

Will Morgan Stanley's named Section 16 officers conduct additional discretionary open-market sales exceeding $10M in aggregate during Q2 2026?

Resolves July 15, 2026(92d)
IG: 0.64

Current Prediction

62%
Likely Yes
Model Agreement88%
Predictions9 runs
Last UpdatedApril 13, 2026

Why This Question Matters

The January 2026 unanimous Section 16 officer selling cluster was the behavioral counter-signal to the 'higher plane' narrative. A repeat cluster in Q2 2026 post-Q1-earnings would strengthen the MIXED governance assessment toward MISALIGNED. Cessation would reduce concerns.

GOVERNANCE_ALIGNMENT

Prediction Distribution

0%25%50%75%100%
opus
sonnet
haiku
Range: 58%65%Aggregate: 62%
Individual Predictions(9 runs)
opusRun 1
65%

The January 2026 cluster was a clear pattern of coordinated post-earnings window discretionary selling. PSU vesting in Q2 creates fresh tranches to sell. The culture allows discretionary sales. Counter: governance optics after the Jan cluster will be scrutinized. The $10M threshold is modest given Jan was $25M+. Lean YES at 65%.

Established pattern from JanQ2 vesting creates tranches$10M modest vs Jan $25M
opusRun 2
60%

The pattern is established but stock has declined 13% from the January peak, reducing the attractiveness of another cluster at current prices. Executives may wait for stock to recover toward $180+ before selling again. However, Q2 window opens post-Q1 earnings and vesting cycles continue. Lean YES at 60%.

Stock down 13% reduces sell appealQ2 window opens post-earningsVesting cycles continue
opusRun 3
58%

The $10M threshold is absolute not incremental, so it requires meaningful aggregate selling in Q2. Given the Jan cluster at $25M, repeating it or hitting $10M specifically is plausible. The governance scrutiny factor pushes probability down somewhat. Net around 58%.

$10M absolute thresholdJan $25M precedentGovernance scrutiny counter
sonnetRun 1
62%

The Jan 2026 pattern strongly favors YES. Stock recovery toward $170-180 range would make Q2 window attractive. $10M is achievable if even 4-5 executives sell at typical discretionary sizes.

Jan pattern favors YES$10M achievable with 4-5 execsRange attractive for Q2 window
sonnetRun 2
65%

Strong precedent plus predictable vesting plus modest threshold. Lean YES at 65%. The governance optics concern is real but the pattern was already public for Q1 and did not stop the cluster.

Strong precedentPredictable vestingGovernance optics did not stop Jan
sonnetRun 3
60%

The Jan precedent is clear but Q2 may see adjustment toward 10b5-1 plans instead of discretionary. The resolution criteria exclude 10b5-1, which materially reduces the probability of hitting $10M in discretionary alone. Lean YES at 60% but with uncertainty about the 10b5-1 substitution.

10b5-1 substitution riskJan precedent clearResolution excludes 10b5-1
haikuRun 1
62%

Lean YES at 62%. Strong Jan precedent plus vesting cycles.

Strong precedentVesting cyclesLean YES
haikuRun 2
60%

Lean YES given precedent but the stock decline and governance scrutiny create modest headwinds. 60%.

Lean YESStock decline headwindGovernance scrutiny
haikuRun 3
65%

The pattern is too strong to discount. $10M is modest. Lean YES at 65%.

Pattern too strongModest threshold65%

Resolution Criteria

Resolves YES if Morgan Stanley named executive officers (NEOs in the most recent proxy) file Form 4 disclosures showing cumulative discretionary open-market sales (excluding tax withholding dispositions and 10b5-1 pre-planned sales) exceeding $10M in aggregate between April 14, 2026 and June 30, 2026. Resolves NO otherwise.

Resolution Source

SEC EDGAR Form 4 filings for Morgan Stanley insiders

Source Trigger

Executive Discretionary Selling — additional discretionary (non-10b5-1) selling in Q2 2026 post-Q1-earnings window

insider-investigatorGOVERNANCE_ALIGNMENTHIGH
View MS Analysis

Full multi-lens equity analysis