Archived research. Equity forecasting is part of the Runchey Research archive (methodology era 1) and is no longer actively updated. Everything remains published at its original URL. Browse the archive
Will Morgan Stanley's Q1 2026 reported EPS exceed consensus estimates by at least $0.05?
Reported $3.43 EPS ex-DVA vs ~$3.02-$3.06 consensus → +$0.37-$0.41 beat (clears $0.05 threshold).
Prediction Score
Final Prediction
Why This Question Matters
With richly priced expectations, any miss could trigger multiple compression regardless of fundamentals. A beat of $0.05+ supports the narrative; in-line or miss tests whether the 'higher plane' premium is durable.
Prediction Distribution
Individual Predictions(9 runs)
MS has beaten consensus in 7 of last 8 quarters with typical beat magnitude $0.08-$0.15. $0.05 is a modest threshold. Q4 momentum and buyback share count reduction support. However, rich multiple pressures analysts to raise estimates, tightening the window. Lean YES moderately.
Base rate of beating by $0.05+ for MS is approximately 65% historically. The rich multiple reduces this somewhat because analysts model more aggressively. Pick's cautionary language in Q4 may have made sell-side tighten estimates. Net around 55%.
Narrative pressure works both ways — it raises consensus but also creates bias toward conservative guidance. Management tends to guide low to beat. The DCP transition noise could go either direction. $0.05 is low enough to clear with normal execution. Lean YES.
Typical MS beat is 65-75% base rate. Adjust down slightly for richer multiple pressure on estimates. Around 58%.
Moderate lean YES. Beat history and low threshold support, but rich expectations work against.
Close to 50/50. The beat base rate is strong but the narrative premium creates selection bias on consensus. Analyst estimates for Q1 may already embed the strong trajectory, tightening the beat window.
Base rate suggests beat is likely. $0.05 is modest. Lean YES around 57%.
Beat history strong but rich multiple tightens consensus. Moderate lean YES at 55%.
Typical MS beat is more than $0.05. Lean YES at 58%.
Resolution Criteria
Resolves YES if Morgan Stanley's Q1 2026 reported diluted EPS exceeds the mean sell-side consensus estimate by at least $0.05 at the time of earnings release, per FactSet or Refinitiv consensus. Resolves NO otherwise.
Resolution Source
Morgan Stanley Q1 2026 earnings release vs FactSet/Refinitiv consensus
Source Trigger
Narrative validation via Q1 2026 earnings — does MS clear the higher plane bar on reported EPS
Full multi-lens equity analysis