Archived research. Equity forecasting is part of the Runchey Research archive (methodology era 1) and is no longer actively updated. Everything remains published at its original URL. Browse the archive

Back to Forecasting
MSActive

Will Morgan Stanley's Q2 2026 reported EPS exceed consensus estimates by at least $0.05?

Resolves July 25, 2026
IG: 0.80

Current Prediction

54%
Likely Yes
Model Agreement95%
Predictions9 runs
Last UpdatedApril 29, 2026

Prediction Distribution

0%25%50%75%100%
opus
sonnet
haiku
Range: 50%58%Aggregate: 54%
Individual Predictions(9 runs)
opusRun 1
54%

Q1 2026 was a +13.6% EPS blowout, which historically triggers sell-side estimate revisions that overshoot by 2-4 percentage points of beat probability for the next quarter. With stock at $194.59 52-week high, analysts face strong pressure to raise. Q2 2025 base ($2.13) is favorable for growth optics but consensus will reset higher. Lean YES modestly.

Post-blowout sell-side overshoot riskStock at 52-week high pressures analystsModest $0.05 threshold still beatable
opusRun 2
50%

Tail-risk frame: Q2 first full quarter under DCP-derivative hedging transition; advisory pop in Q1 (+74% YoY) likely flushed pent-up backlog reducing Q2 momentum; tax rate likely reverts toward 22-23% guide eliminating Q1's low-tax tailwind. These three Q2-specific headwinds cluster against a tightened consensus. Coin-flip.

DCP transition Q2 first clean quarterAdvisory pop flush riskTax rate reverts higher
opusRun 3
56%

Second-order: management tradition of conservative guide + buyback share-count reduction continuing + NII guided to modest Q2 increase + Wealth fee-based momentum supports beat. The $0.05 threshold is small relative to the typical $0.10-0.20 beat magnitude. Slight lean YES.

Conservative guidance traditionShare-count reduction tailwindThreshold small vs typical beat
sonnetRun 1
55%

Base rate ~70% beat, adjusted down ~15 pts for post-blowout estimate compression and the higher consensus floor. Wealth momentum and ISG records support; tax rate reversion offsets. Around 55%.

Base rate 70% adjusted -15 ptsWealth momentum supportsTax reversion offset
sonnetRun 2
52%

After a blowout quarter, sell-side rebalances. Q1 2026 was the 7th beat in 8 quarters but +13.6% magnitude is unusual — analysts raised Q2 estimates aggressively. Coin-flip with slight YES tilt.

Sell-side rebalances after blowoutAggressive estimate raisesSlight YES tilt
sonnetRun 3
50%

True 50/50. Q2 has multiple competing forces: DCP completed (neutral), tax reverts (negative), Wealth momentum (positive), IB advisory comp tougher (negative). Net flat.

Competing forces balanceTax reverts negativeWealth momentum positive
haikuRun 1
58%

MS beats consistently; threshold modest. Lean YES at 58%.

Beats consistentlyModest thresholdLean YES
haikuRun 2
55%

Strong Q1 momentum suggests Q2 follow-through, but analysts will raise. Moderate YES at 55%.

Q1 momentum carriesAnalyst raises offsetModerate YES
haikuRun 3
53%

Beat history strong but post-blowout consensus is taut. Slight YES at 53%.

Beat historyPost-blowout consensus tightSlight YES

Resolution Criteria

Resolves YES if Morgan Stanley's Q2 2026 reported diluted EPS exceeds the mean sell-side consensus estimate by at least $0.05 at the time of earnings release, per FactSet or Refinitiv consensus. Resolves NO otherwise.

Resolution Source

Morgan Stanley Q2 2026 earnings release vs FactSet/Refinitiv consensus

Source Trigger

Narrative validation via Q2 2026 earnings — does MS clear the higher plane bar on reported EPS for a second consecutive quarter

myth-meterEXPECTATIONS_PRICEDHIGH
View MS Analysis

Full multi-lens equity analysis