Nebraska: every source prices Osborn further behind than the polls have him
UnclassifiedClosed October 8: the spread between sources was 9.5 points on the October 7 and 8 boards, from 10.9 on October 5, as FiftyPlusOne rose from 17.6% to 19.1% and Kalshi fell from 28.5% to 27.5%; DDHQ is at 18%. The split in markdown remains: against a poll average of Ricketts +0.9, the market takes 3 points off Osborn, the models 5 and 4.8, against his 5.1-point miss in 2024.
The one measured miss for this candidate in this state is 5.1 points (2024). With the poll average at Ricketts +1.0, the models' markdowns of 4.9 and 5.1 match it and the market's 2.7 falls short. The October 3 lean went to the market, whose 5-point markdown then matched the miss against an average of Osborn +1.1; the averages updated October 2 to 4 moved the comparison, not the prices.
Why these should match, and what could explain the gap
The two models agree with each other to within 1.2 points, which usually marks a number the market also accepts. Here the market was 10.5 to 10.9 points above them on October 5 and 6, and is 9.5 and 8.4 above them now. All three mark Osborn's polling down: the market by 3 points, DDHQ by 5 and FiftyPlusOne by 4.8, against 5, 7 and 6.8 on October 2. The poll average moved from Osborn +1.1 on October 2 to Ricketts +1.0 on October 5 and Ricketts +0.9 now, after FiftyPlusOne's average moved from Ricketts +0.9 to +0.4 on October 6; 270toWin (October 2) has Ricketts +1.6 and Silver Bulletin (October 4) +0.6. The newest poll in the table, YouGov, fielded September 24 to October 3, has Osborn 48, Ricketts 47. Silver Bulletin's forecast, read once on October 4 and not a board source, takes 3.7 off its own average and has Osborn at 24.7%, between the market and the models.
- In 2024 the final average had Osborn 1.6 behind and he lost by 6.7, a 5.1-point miss.
- The contract may also carry the value of a 50-49-1 Senate, where Osborn would decide who organizes the chamber.
- Trump carried Nebraska by 20.6. The only out-party challenger to win a midterm Senate race in a state that red since 2006 was Jon Tester in Montana that year.